Pro Insights to Strengthen Your Story
Our manuscript evaluation helps you understand what’s working—and what’s not—so your book reaches its full potential.
Raise Your Glasses
By Phyllis Shindler
A Celebration of 50 yrs of KISS songs by Celebrities, Musicians and Fans
The Secret World of Maggie Grey
By Drew Collins
The Secret World of Maggie Grey: A vampire, a witch, and a siren get accepted into a magical HBCU
Let’s Review Your Manuscript Together
We got all the good stuff that will make your book stand out for all the right reasons.
Professional Book
Formatting
Proofreading
Services
Children's Book
Editing Services
Review
Services
Academic
Proofreading
Business
Proofreading
Clarity Before You Revise
Every strong book begins with a clear roadmap. A manuscript evaluation gives you professional feedback on your story’s structure, pacing, characters, tone, and more—before you dive into edits. At Ottenheimer Publishers, our editorial team carefully assesses your manuscript and provides a detailed report outlining what’s working, what needs improvement, and actionable next steps. Whether you’re just wrapping your first draft or refining before submission, we’ll help you move forward with purpose and clarity.
Our Manuscript Evaluation Process
From Raw Draft to Clear Direction
Our editor reads your manuscript thoroughly to assess overall quality.
You receive a report covering plot, character development, structure, pacing, and voice.
We provide tailored suggestions to help strengthen your book’s marketability and narrative impact.
Optional follow-up consultation to map out revisions and editing strategy.
Evaluation That Moves the Needle
A manuscript evaluation is the foundation for an effective revision plan. It helps you understand how readers—and publishers—will see your work.
Why Authors Choose Us:
- Objective Editorial Insight Honest feedback from publishing professionals
- Actionable Feedback Clear notes that guide your revision process
- Pre-Edit Confidence Know what’s working before investing in editing
- Tailored Recommendations Based on your genre, goals, and audience
Book a Free Consultation With Our Experts
We’re here to support your writing process and help your manuscript reach its highest potential.
What to Expect:- A 30-minute one-on-one session to discuss your manuscript and goals
- Assessment of where your book stands and what’s needed next
- Overview of our evaluation process and timeline
- Transparent quote and tailored feedback plan
- Clear next steps to move your project forward
How You Can Benefit from a Manuscript Evaluation
- First-Time Authors Gain direction and clarity on your early drafts
- Experienced Writers Receive professional feedback before final edits
- Self-Publishing Authors Ensure quality before moving to formatting or publishing
- Querying Writers Strengthen your book before submitting to agents or publishers
- Writers in Revision Break through creative blocks with strategic insight
Authors Who Found Clarity
4.9
Reviews
Powered By
Anika Rhodes
Author of Unspoken RoadsI was stuck in the revision phase for months. The evaluation gave me the exact feedback I needed to move forward with confidence.
Rated 4.5/5.0
Tom Reed
Author of Dark HarvestThe editorial report was thorough and on point. It helped me reshape my novel and prepare for a successful launch.
Rated 4.5/5.0
Julia Banks
Author of The Dust We CarryThe feedback felt professional and constructive. I knew what to fix, and I finally had a path forward.
Rated 4.5/5.0
Anika Rhodes
Author of Unspoken RoadsI was stuck in the revision phase for months. The evaluation gave me the exact feedback I needed to move forward with confidence.
Rated 4.5/5.0
Tom Reed
Author of Dark HarvestThe editorial report was thorough and on point. It helped me reshape my novel and prepare for a successful launch.
Rated 4.5/5.0
Julia Banks
Author of The Dust We CarryThe feedback felt professional and constructive. I knew what to fix, and I finally had a path forward.
Rated 4.5/5.0
Your Evaluation Questions Answered
It’s a professional assessment of your manuscript’s strengths and weaknesses, including structure, tone, pacing, and more.
Yes, but it doesn’t have to be perfect. We review complete drafts that are ready for a high-level critique.
No. An evaluation is not a line-by-line edit. It’s a strategic overview of how to improve your manuscript before editing.
Yes. You’ll receive a detailed editorial report with suggestions and next steps.
You can revise independently or move forward with our editing services to continue refining your book.